Misconduct and Serious Misconduct: A Guide For Employers

Misconduct vs serious misconduct: why does it matter?

In an ideal world, employers and business owners wouldn’t need to deal with a team member committing an act that can be classified as misconduct or serious misconduct. However, as people leaders, we know that people problems are an inevitable part of having employees and running a business.

You might encounter misconduct and serious misconduct in the course of the employment lifecycle. Let’s go through what these are, how they’re different from each other, and when they might warrant HR help.

 

What is misconduct?

Misconduct generally refers to employee behaviour that breaches workplace policies, rules or the standards of conduct reasonably expected in their role.

Examples of behaviour that may constitute misconduct, depending on the circumstances, include:

  • misusing company property
  • poor time-keeping
  • unauthorised absence from work
  • minor violations of safety practices
  • failure to comply with workplace dress or presentation standards
  • disruptive behaviour
  • poor conduct

The seriousness of misconduct will depend on the circumstances, including the nature of the behaviour, whether it was intentional or repeated, the employee’s explanation and its impact on the workplace.

What is serious misconduct?

Serious misconduct is defined under regulation 1.07 of the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth). The regulation identifies conduct that may constitute serious misconduct, including:

  • causes serious and imminent risk to the health and safety of another person or to the reputation or profits of their employer’s business
  • deliberately behaves in a way that’s inconsistent with continuing their employment.

Examples of serious misconduct include (but are not limited to):

  • theft
  • fraud
  • assault
  • sexual harassment
  • intoxication at work
  • deliberately falsifying documentation
  • refusing to follow a lawful and reasonable instruction that is consistent with the employee’s employment contract

Circumstances must be assessed before deciding whether behaviour constitutes serious misconduct.

Misconduct vs serious misconduct: why does it matter?

The distinction matters because it can affect the disciplinary action an employer considers and whether dismissal without notice may be justified.

Depending on the circumstances, less severe misconduct may be addressed through counselling, clear expectations, training or formal warnings, while serious misconduct may warrant immediate dismissal without notice or payment in lieu of notice.

How about entitlements? Outstanding wages and unused annual leave remain payable, with long service leave payable in some circumstances (Fair Work Ombudsman).

However, serious misconduct does not automatically make a dismissal fair. Before deciding on disciplinary action, employers should establish the relevant facts, clearly communicate the allegations, provide the employee with a reasonable opportunity to respond and consider their response before reaching a decision.

Small business employers must also consider the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code, which allows summary dismissal where the employer believes, on reasonable grounds, that the employee’s conduct is sufficiently serious to justify immediate dismissal.

What about employee entitlements? Where dismissal for serious misconduct is justified, employers are generally not required to provide notice or payment in lieu under the National Employment Standards. However, outstanding wages and unused annual leave must still be paid, along with any other applicable entitlements, including long service leave where payable. Employers should also check any applicable award, enterprise agreement or employment contract.

For further information, visit the Fair Work Ombudsman.

 

Which workplace laws may apply?

Several Australian workplace laws may be relevant when managing misconduct and serious misconduct. The requirements depend on the nature of the behaviour and the circumstances of each case.

 

Fair Work Act 2009 and Fair Work Regulations 2009

Regulation 1.07 under the FW Act defines serious misconduct and details the examples of behaviour that could fall under the classification.

 

Sex Discrimination Act 1984

The Sex Discrimination Act 1984 places a positive duty on employers to take reasonable and proportionate measures to eliminate, as far as possible, sex discrimination in a work context, sexual harassment, sex-based harassment, workplace environments that are hostile on the ground of sex, and related acts of victimisation. This Act highlights the responsibility employers have in ensuring that their workplace is a safe and respectful one, free from gender-based discrimination and harassment.

Positive duty means taking reasonable and proportionate measures to eliminate relevant unlawful conduct as soon as possible.

 

Work Health and Safety laws

Applicable state and territory work health and safety (WHS) or occupational health and safety (OHS) legislation requires employers to manage risks to workers’ physical and psychological health and safety.

Allegations involving bullying, harassment, violence or unsafe behaviour may therefore require immediate risk management measures, alongside any workplace investigation or disciplinary process.

 

Other legislation, applicable modern awards, enterprise agreements, employment contracts and workplace policies may also be relevant. Employers should consider these obligations together when determining the appropriate response.

 

What should employers do when encountering misconduct or serious misconduct?

Have clear rules in place

Your employees cannot be expected to know the rules if they are not aware of them in the first place.

Having clear policies that set expectations and standards of behaviour is not enough. Employees also need to be able to have access to them and should know what each policy entails.

An employee handbook is one of the most effective ways to make employees aware of which policies you have in your business. At Now Actually, we create employee handbooks that also clearly outline what misconduct and serious misconduct are, as well as the consequences for incidents that constitute these.

Know how to act and address allegations when they arise

In the event of an allegation of misconduct or serious misconduct being raised, knowing what to do and how to address it is key. Ignoring the issue or not responding appropriately can leave your business exposed to risk and worsen the situation.

Dealing with a complaint is not always straightforward. Not all complaints require an investigation, while some allegations are serious enough to warrant an independent third party.

We created a workplace complaint triage checklist that you can download here for free.

Consult an expert

There are times when a business does not have an internal HR resource that can deal with an incident, especially when it’s one where serious misconduct or a serious breach of policy is involved. Our best practice recommendation for this is to always seek advice from an expert and mitigate any risk your company might be exposed to.

 

Need help with a complex incident or an impartial assessment? If you:

  • Are uncertain about whether behaviour constitutes misconduct or serious misconduct,
  • Need help with assessing allegations and deciding on an appropriate response and next steps,
  • Are considering a dismissal or termination

Why not give Now Actually a call? Our HR Partners have years of experience in dealing with tricky and complicated scenarios. Contact Now Actually today.

Book Your Discovery Call